• Agenda
  • Initiatives
  • Reports
  • Events
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • Leadership and Governance
    • Our Members and Partners
    • Communities
    • History
    • Klaus Schwab
    • Media
    • Contact Us
    • Careers
    • World Economic Forum USA
    • Privacy and Terms of Use
  • EN ES FR 日本語 中文
  • Login to TopLink

We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By using our website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our updated Cookie Notice.

I accept
    Hamburger
  • World Economic Forum Logo
  • Agenda
  • Initiatives
  • Reports
  • Events
  • About
  • TopLink
  • Search Cancel

Home Page

<Previous Next>
  • Introduction
  • Executive Summaries
  • Global Shifts
    • Stefanie Babst, NATO – Rethinking Our Approach to Global Security
    • Jeremy Bentham, Royal Dutch Shell Plc – Reframing the Climate Change Debate
    • Wayne Best, Visa Inc – Demographics and Demand
    • Jean-Claude Burgelman, European Commission – A “New Deal” on Green Growth
    • Jakkie Cilliers, Institute for Security Studies – Reclaiming Legitimacy in Global Governance
    • Thomas E. Cremins, NASA – A New Space Age
    • Kristel Van der Elst, The Global Foresight Group – Rethinking Ageing
    • Tina Fordham, Citigroup – Vox Populi Risk
    • Julius Gatune, African Centre for Economic Transformation – Rethinking the Informal Economy
    • Jerome Glenn, The Millennium Project – The Age of Conscious-Technology
    • Derrick Gosselin, SCK.CEN – Predictive Analytics
    • Stefan Hajkowicz, CSIRO – The Potential of the Creative Economy
    • Kathleen Hicks, CSIS – New Security Challenges Posed by Megacities
    • Claudia Juech, The Rockefeller Foundation – Economic Opportunities in the 21st Century
    • Katell Le Goulven, UNICEF – Agile Development
    • Chris Luebkeman, Arup Group Ltd – Ambient Technology in Cities
    • Marios Maratheftis, Standard Chartered Bank – Shifting Geo-Economic Power
    • Daizo Motoyoshi, LIXIL Group Corporation – Revival of Japan
    • Herbert Oberhänsli, Nestlé SA – Rethinking Freshwater
    • Seongwon Park, STEPI – The Rising Appeal of a De-Growth Future
    • Rafael Ramírez, University of Oxford – The Possible Future of the Economics Profession
    • Rogerio Rizzi de Oliveira, Hewlett-Packard Company – Improving the Quality of Life in Megacities
    • Nouriel Roubini, New York University – The Third Industrial Revolution
    • Francisco Sagasti, FORO Nacional Internacional – The Changing Nature of Livelihoods
    • Trudpert Schelb, Siemens AG – The Next Stage of Individualization
    • Peter Schwartz, Salesforce – Fundamental Technological Progress Driving Economic Growth
    • Angela Wilkinson, OECD – Progressing Well-Being through Inclusive Growth
    • Jill Wong, Singapore Government – The Impact of Automation on Jobs and Society
  • Videos
  • Acknowledgements
  • Browse by Topic
    • Issues
      • Ageing
      • Cities and Urbanization
      • Economics Growth and Development
      • Employment and Entrepreneurship
      • Environment and Sustainability
      • Science and Technology
      • Security and Governance
    • Industries
      • Aviation and Travel
      • Electronics
      • Engineering and Construction
      • Global Health and Healthcare
      • Infrastructure
      • IT Software and Services
      • Media Entertainment and Information
      • Oil and Gas
      • Retail Consumer Goods and Lifestyle
      • Telecommunications
Global Strategic Foresight Community Home Previous Next
  • Report Home
  • Introduction
  • Executive Summaries
  • Global Shifts
    • Stefanie Babst, NATO – Rethinking Our Approach to Global Security
    • Jeremy Bentham, Royal Dutch Shell Plc – Reframing the Climate Change Debate
    • Wayne Best, Visa Inc – Demographics and Demand
    • Jean-Claude Burgelman, European Commission – A “New Deal” on Green Growth
    • Jakkie Cilliers, Institute for Security Studies – Reclaiming Legitimacy in Global Governance
    • Thomas E. Cremins, NASA – A New Space Age
    • Kristel Van der Elst, The Global Foresight Group – Rethinking Ageing
    • Tina Fordham, Citigroup – Vox Populi Risk
    • Julius Gatune, African Centre for Economic Transformation – Rethinking the Informal Economy
    • Jerome Glenn, The Millennium Project – The Age of Conscious-Technology
    • Derrick Gosselin, SCK.CEN – Predictive Analytics
    • Stefan Hajkowicz, CSIRO – The Potential of the Creative Economy
    • Kathleen Hicks, CSIS – New Security Challenges Posed by Megacities
    • Claudia Juech, The Rockefeller Foundation – Economic Opportunities in the 21st Century
    • Katell Le Goulven, UNICEF – Agile Development
    • Chris Luebkeman, Arup Group Ltd – Ambient Technology in Cities
    • Marios Maratheftis, Standard Chartered Bank – Shifting Geo-Economic Power
    • Daizo Motoyoshi, LIXIL Group Corporation – Revival of Japan
    • Herbert Oberhänsli, Nestlé SA – Rethinking Freshwater
    • Seongwon Park, STEPI – The Rising Appeal of a De-Growth Future
    • Rafael Ramírez, University of Oxford – The Possible Future of the Economics Profession
    • Rogerio Rizzi de Oliveira, Hewlett-Packard Company – Improving the Quality of Life in Megacities
    • Nouriel Roubini, New York University – The Third Industrial Revolution
    • Francisco Sagasti, FORO Nacional Internacional – The Changing Nature of Livelihoods
    • Trudpert Schelb, Siemens AG – The Next Stage of Individualization
    • Peter Schwartz, Salesforce – Fundamental Technological Progress Driving Economic Growth
    • Angela Wilkinson, OECD – Progressing Well-Being through Inclusive Growth
    • Jill Wong, Singapore Government – The Impact of Automation on Jobs and Society
  • Videos
  • Acknowledgements
  • Browse by Topic
    • Issues
      • Ageing
      • Cities and Urbanization
      • Economics Growth and Development
      • Employment and Entrepreneurship
      • Environment and Sustainability
      • Science and Technology
      • Security and Governance
    • Industries
      • Aviation and Travel
      • Electronics
      • Engineering and Construction
      • Global Health and Healthcare
      • Infrastructure
      • IT Software and Services
      • Media Entertainment and Information
      • Oil and Gas
      • Retail Consumer Goods and Lifestyle
      • Telecommunications
  • Economics Growth and Development
  • Security and Governance


Vox Populi Risk
A Future Where Aggregate Economic Growth No Longer Guarantees Political Stability

Tina Fordham, Citigroup

 

Fuelled by widening inequality, perceptions of elite corruption and middle-class anxieties about globalization, protests and volatility in public opinion pose ongoing, fast-moving risks to the business and investment environment. In contrast to previous waves of political risk, which were often concentrated in less developed, lower-income countries, this new Vox Populi risk is increasingly manifesting itself in middle-income emerging market and industrialized countries. While, historically, protests have subsided with the return of economic growth, we are seeing that aggregate economic growth may no longer guarantee political stability. Vox Populi risk threatens to fuel uncertainty and may therefore hold back economic recovery, which would in turn reduce the scope for governments to respond to popular discontent. We need to find creative political solutions to break out of this vicious circle.

 


Share

Author

9---Fordham

 

Tina Fordham

Managing Director, Chief Global Political Analyst, Citigroup 

Author

9---Fordham

 

Tina Fordham

Managing Director, Chief Global Political Analyst, Citigroup 

Disclaimer

All opinions expressed herein are those of the authors. The World Economic Forum provides an independent and impartial platform dedicated to generating debate around the key topics that shape global, regional and industry agendas.

Disclaimer

All opinions expressed herein are those of the authors. The World Economic Forum provides an independent and impartial platform dedicated to generating debate around the key topics that shape global, regional and industry agendas.

Highlight

Tweet
Are we entering a world where economic growth no longer guarantees political stability?

Highlight

Tweet
Are we entering a world where economic growth no longer guarantees political stability?
“Vox Populi risk” refers to shifting and more volatile public opinion that poses ongoing, fast-moving risks to the business and investment environment. A shift may now be occurring whereby aggregate economic growth no longer guarantees political stability; fuelled by widening inequality, perceptions of elite corruption and middle-class anxieties about globalization, could Vox Populi risk become a more permanent feature of the global business and political environment? And what should be done about it? 

It seems like political risk is in the headlines every day: popular protests, demands for independence, military coups, civil conflict. Citi’s Political Analysis team has documented a dramatic increase in the number of elections, mass protests and government collapses in major markets over the past three years − up 54% on the previous decade, from an average of 14.1 to 21.7 − as well as a proliferation of new, fringe and anti-establishment political parties. 

In contrast to previous waves of political risk – which were often concentrated in less developed, lower-income countries and which subsided with the return of economic growth – Vox Populi risk is manifesting itself in middle-income emerging market and industrialized countries which are deeply integrated into the global economy and financial system and where growth is recovering after the recent crisis. Vox Populi risk is therefore becoming less localized and more potentially systemic.

In our view, the new Vox Populi risk is being fuelled by growing perceptions of income inequality and anxiety about globalization, particularly among middle classes. In developed markets, this has resulted largely in increased appetite for alternative political parties, which have seen an unprecedented spike in support from 2011-2014. This has sapped political capital from governments, prompted fragile multi-party governing coalitions and often surprised markets by producing unexpected election outcomes. 

Mass protests have also swept through middle-income emerging market countries – despite their governments having delivered sustained growth and improved living standards. There is a greater prevalence of street demonstrations, rebellions and sustained tensions that elections fail to resolve. In some cases, such as Ukraine in 2013, local protests can rapidly spiral into geopolitical risk. 

Around the world, grassroots pressures are increasing the risk of fragmentation – social, political and even geographical – as anti-government, anti-establishment sentiment reaches all-time highs and trust in institutions plummets. The Occupy movement’s framing of the 99% versus the 1%, pitting elites against the overwhelming majority, has resonated with middle classes across both developed and emerging markets.

It increasingly seems that aggregate economic growth will no longer guarantee political stability. In developed markets, there is a sense that the social contract – support of the incumbent party in return for rising living standards – has been broken. The global financial and economic crisis has rolled back middle-class living standards, for the first time in decades in some countries. In 2013, Pew reported a majority of people believing their children will be worse off financially than they are themselves, even in countries where growth had returned.8 In many instances, such as the United States, this represented a historical change in trend. In France, this majority was as high as 90%; in Japan, 78%.

In middle-income emerging markets, public expectations are growing and perceptions of elite corruption have frequently been the catalyst for mass protests. Time and again, evidence of elite misbehaviour has galvanized public dissatisfaction across income groups and regions, accelerated by the growing penetration of social media – yet the resulting protests have not necessarily improved the situation, either resulting in tensions remaining high without a change in leadership, or the election of a weaker leader with less political capital.

Economically, Vox Populi risk threatens to fuel uncertainty, leading households to save more and making businesses nervous about investing. In other words, it will reduce two major components of domestic aggregate demand. Chief executive officers consistently cite uncertainty as a factor that weighs heavily on their capital spending decisions. Vox Populi risk may therefore dissuade companies from hiring and expanding, thereby holding back economic recovery – which in turn will reduce the scope for governments to respond to popular discontent. 

The danger, then, is of a vicious circle, with weak elected leaders facing legislative gridlock and constrained by austerity budgets, pursuing short-termist and populist policy-making because instability gives them no mandate to undertake necessary structural reforms. 

Can we think of creative political solutions to break out of this vicious circle? How can we create expectations of stability and future prosperity, which may themselves become self-fulfilling? 

While voter participation rates are steadily declining, especially among the young, the rise in Vox Populi risk clearly indicates a strong public demand for political alternatives. That means there is an opportunity in Vox Populi risk, if we can find ways to engage especially the young productively in the political process. Vox Populi risk also suggests that successful efforts to tackle corruption and income inequality could have benefits that are widespread and profound. While we see Vox Populi risk as systemic and likely to be with us for some time, it does not have to be.

8
8 Pew Research Global Attitudes Project, Citi Research. Surveys conducted March-April 2013, margins of error ranging +/- 3.3-7.7%.
Back to Top
Subscribe for updates
A weekly update of what’s on the Global Agenda
Follow Us
About
Our Mission
Leadership and Governance
Our Members and Partners
The Fourth Industrial Revolution
Centre for the Fourth Industrial Revolution
Communities
History
Klaus Schwab
Our Impact
Media
Pictures
A Global Platform for Geostrategic Collaboration
Careers
Open Forum
Contact Us
Mapping Global Transformations
Code of Conduct
World Economic Forum LLC
Sustainability
World Economic Forum Privacy Policy
Media
News
Accreditation
Subscribe to our news
Members & Partners
Member login to TopLink
Strategic Partners' area
Partner Institutes' area
Global sites
Centre for the Fourth Industrial Revolution
Open Forum
Global Shapers
Schwab Foundation for Social Entrepreneurship
EN ES FR 日本語 中文
© 2022 World Economic Forum
Privacy Policy & Terms of Service